October 25, 2012

My Gut Reaction: Kendrick Lamar - good kid, m.A.A.d. city (October 22, 2012)

I know, I know: this is the guy from Compton that you two actually wanted me to write about this week.  Remember how I told you to trust me?


Kendrick Lamar Duckworth, who used to rhyme under the alias K-Dot but eventually switched over to two-thirds of his given name, is a Compton, California-based blogger's darling who has just released his major label debut, good kid, m.A.A.d. city, on Aftermath/Interscope under the executive production guidance of Dr. Dre himself.  He managed to swing this after spending the early days of his career unleashing free mixtapes and Internet-only albums to the public: this caused him to amass a large Interweb following that the majors couldn't ignore for much longer.

good kid, m.A.A.d. city is subtitled A Short Film By Kendrick Lamar, and it is as ambitious an attempt as one might expect: it's a loosely-formed concept album based around Kendrick's life growing up in Compton, and the trials, tribulations, and triumphs that came with it.  It's also only twelve tracks long, which is ambitious in a different way.  The fact that he didn't feel the need to stuff the project with every single idea he's ever had musically speaks volumes for the man's confidence in his own abilities: he knows he'll be around for a while, even if just on the Internet.

good kid, m.A.A.d. city is actually the second project effort from his crew, Black Hippy, to hit store shelves (colleague Jay Rock's solo debut, Follow Me Home, was released by Strange Music, a label I had never heard of but one with enough pull to release the project and cause my local library to take notice and purchase at least one copy for lending purposes).  Black Hippy, made up K-Dot, Jay Rock, Ab-Soul, and Schoolboy Q, have been making their respective marks on our chosen genre for quite a while now, with numerous mixtapes and Interweb albums filling the space in their combined back catalog.  Most of what the Black Hippy crew has released has been hailed by critics as new and refreshing, or at the very least entertaining.  Curiously, only Jay Rock plays a co-starring role on Kendrick's album, but that's more because Kendrick was attempting to tell a cohesive story and didn't want to get bogged down in the drama.  However, that doesn't mean they weren't around to support their boy (*cough* bonus tracks *cough*).

good kid, m.A.A.d. city joins the ranks of debut albums executive produced by Dr. Dre, an exclusive list that includes Snoop Dogg and the major label debuts from The Game, Eminem, and 50 Cent, which essentially means that Kendrick is all but guaranteed a spot on the mythical Detox album that's never materializing.  However, unlike with those other artists named, Dre doesn't write Kendrick any prescriptions for his project.  How does one work alongside Dr. Dre so extensively and not secure at least one Dre beat?  To me, this just means that we need to watch out for a random leak from K-Dot himself in the near future.

Here we go.

1.  SHERANE A.K.A. MASTER SPLINTER'S DAUGHTER
As a pop culture nerd, that song title appeals to me, but goofy reference aside, this wasn't bad.  After an introductory prayer where the distorted vocals creeped me out and I now have evil spirits living in my iPod, K-Dot launches into a one-verse wonder about a girl named Sherane who he met back in high school (so the note about her being only seventeen isn't all that disturbing, although it is made known that he was only in the tenth grade at the time, so wouldn't she have been brought up on statutory rape charges?  But I digress), and although the story ventures into typical "bitch set me up" territory (if you're familiar at all with the non-titular characters from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, that song title will suddenly make a lot more sense), Kendrick's attention to the little details makes this track much more entertaining that it should be, with an assist from the instrumental from Tha Bizness, which was simple and effective enough.  The voicemail outro was a bit goofy ans ran for far too long, but Kendrick is trying to tell a story here, so I'll let it ride.

2.  BITCH, DON'T KILL MY VIBE
The first track on good kid, m.A.A.d. city where Kendrick's voice may affect your listening pleasure, thanks to a weakly-performed hook that still lends itself to an easy hashtag-slash-catchphrase that you two will use on your significant others right before being forced to sleep on the couch.  Sounwave's instrumental is quiet when it needs to be, but when the drums kick in, it reminded me a bit too much of "Swimming Pools (Drank)", which isn't a bad thing, but I was expecting something much different.  I did like how K-Dot kept adding new tweaks to the hook while performing said hook toward the end, since it came across as stream-of-consciousness rapping, but otherwise, I'll move on to the next track, if that's okay with you.


3. BACKSEAT FREESTYLE
True to its title, “Backseat Freestyle” is more of a freestyle session that a true song, even though K-Dot provides his own hook throughout. The ubiquitous Hit-Boy, who's been having one hell of a 2012, provides yet another simple, repetitive, and will-get-stuck-in-your-head-but-it's-okay-because-you'll-like-it instrumental, and Kendrick obliges by running around like a kid on a playground filled with swings, slides, and candy. This isn't the best representation of Kendrick Lamar lyrically: hell, at one point he chooses to just repeat the word “beeyotch” a bunch of times. But it's clear that he didn't take this track seriously, which is actually kind of refreshing in today's hip hop world. Not bad.

4. THE ART OF PEER PRESSURE
Allow me one quick moment of sheer juvenile excitement: this shit was awesome. Okay, I'm calm. This song was the shit, as K-Dot's three-verse tale of a night out with the homeys he didn't usually run with is told with clarity, conciseness, and a hurried, hushed tone that will heave you holding your breath. The beat at the very beginning was pretty interesting, as it combined West Coast funk sensibilities with some experimental drums, but when the instrumental switches...fuck, this gets good. The second beat, from Tabu, lifted from the work of the Danish group Suspekt's “Helt Alene” (which I tracked down after listening to this, and even with the obvious language barrier, I thought that shit was dope, too), reaches OutKast “Benz Or Beamer”-levels of dopeness, and it fits the tone of “The Art Of Peer Pressure” like a glove. Four songs in, and we've already stumbled upon something great. This is a good sign.

5. MONEY TREES (FEAT. JAY ROCK)
Smart move, Kendrick, don't even try to match the intensity of “The Art Of Peer Pressure”; instead, he opts to use DJ Dahi's okay-enough beat to discuss the financial stream that comes after a home invasion and to mispronounce the word “bitch” in such an egregious manner that you may want to shut the six-minute-plus track off. I wanted to, anyway. Doing so would cause listeners to miss out on an interesting hook and a cameo from K-Dot's Black Hippy cosplayer Jay Rock, as well as another voicemail interlude that keeps the album's general theme going. I can take or leave this song, though.

6. POETIC JUSTICE (FEAT. DRAKE)
Drizzy pops in to return the favor Kendrick originally gave to him in form of a verse on Take Care. Scoop DeVille's beat samples Janet Jackson's “Anytime, Anyplace” with meh results (although the use of the sample makes the song title retroactively funnier, I guess), but at least Aubrey attacks it as though he were actually alert during the studio session (even though the shit he spits mirrors what he's been getting away with writing for the past few years). Kendrick's contribution was pretty fucking dull: it's almost, almost as though he didn't want Drake to even appear on this album, but felt an obligation to allow him to return said favor, even though he had long since moved on at this point. Pass.

7. GOOD KID (FEAT. PHARRELL)
Apparently this was produced by Pharrell Williams. Not by the Neptunes, but by Pharrell himself. (Although Chad Hugo allegedly contributes some ad-libs somewhere.) And doggone it, “Good Kid” has got to be the most musical thing that motherfucker has conjured up in years. The instrumental sounds like the score to an unreleased indie film featuring Kendrick Lamar trying to survive the elements and save his dog or house or guitar or some shit, I don't know (I'm kind of tired right now). K-Dot's verses form a synergy with the music, as well: shit, even Pharrell's hook wasn't bad. So yeah, I liked this song. That's all I got. Not all of these descriptions will be long, you know.

8. M.A.A.D. CITY (FEAT. MC EIHT)
Kendrick does it again, playing with the audience's natural expectation that the instrumental they hear will be the instrumental the song will end with. The first beat, which houses the first verse, is pretty goddamn good, but the world turns on a dime once Compton's own MC Eiht (the hell? Where the fuck has he been?) steps onto the scene, as producers Sounwave and THC switch everything to a motherfucking boom-bap-esque banger of a beat, and both emcees own the shit out of it. This was nice, son!

9. SWIMMING POOLS (DRANK) (EXTENDED VERSION)
The second single released from good kid, m.A.A.d. City, albeit now in an “extended” form that neither adds nor subtracts from the overall experience. I actually really like this song, as simple as it is (the track glorifies drinking and accomplishes nothing else, although K-Dot does attempt some actual depth within his verses), since the first time I ever really paid attention to it was while driving home drunkenly from a friend's house: the simplistic hook spoke to me (mainly the word “drank”, but still). The T-Minus beat sets a darker tone than what the song itself ever delivers upon, or at least that's what I thought before hearing the extended album version, which tacks on an additional verse that attempts to change the meaning of everything you just heard previous to it. It doesn't quite accomplish its goal, but I still dug this a lot.

10. SING ABOUT ME / I'M DYING OF THIRST
The moment I noticed that “Sing About Me / I'm Dying Of Thirst” was more than twelve minutes long, I screamed. Out loud, no less. Unless it's the final song on a project and it contains a hidden bonus track (or if you're The Roots), there's almost zero reason for a rapper to pull this kind of stunt. Anyway, as you could probably tell from how I typed out the title, this is actually supposed to be two separate songs that share a common theme: Kendrick's dual obsessions with death and salvation. “Sing About Me” has a Like beat that is alright, but K-Dot's lyrics dominate throughout, even during the second verse, where he fades out his own vocals well before he's actually finished (a trait you all know I fucking hate), but then returns for a third verse? Huh? After a brief interlude, we transition into the Shkye Hutch-produced “I'm Dying Of Thirst”, with its superior instrumental and a polarizing K-Dot performance that I enjoyed, but a lot of people may hate (even though he doesn't use a weird accent or anything). There was no real reason in my mind to keep these two tracks together.

11. REAL
After a brief interlude that thoroughly explains what Kendrick meant when he said he was dying of thirst (that technically ended the previous track), our host attempts to become a “Real” boy. Which, apparently, is supposed to happen on this annoying-as-shit song produced by Terrace Martin. My problem isn't so much with K-Dot as much as it is whit guest star Anna Wise, whose hook makes me want to punch a wall. Easily the most fucking godawful song on good kid, m.A.A.d. city, and yes, I realize I still have several songs to go before I should be able to make such a declaration, but fuck it. This was terrible.

12. COMPTON (FEAT. DR. DRE)
good kid, m.A.A.d. city is all about Kendrick Lamar growing up in Compton, so it makes sense that he would end the project with a song blatantly named after it. This celebration of his hometown, one that glosses over the prevalent gang lifestyle, violence, and general economic stressors plaguing the area, is produced by Just Blaze, who seems to pop up but once a quarter with a beat or two, and it sounds okay but not great, as it aims to be an anthem but lands somewhere in “background noise” territory. K-Dot is joined by ultimate Compton spokesperson Dr. Dre, whose rhymes, as expected, take on the cadence of the guy who actually wrote them for him (um, that would be Kendrick), but he recites them well enough. I did find it weird that Dre would boast about having a ton of his own beats with him while rhyming on someone else's instrumental, but whatever: this was an okay enough way to end things.

The deluxe edition of good kid, m.A.A.d city, which should be the only one anyone ever considers purchasing, comes with a bonus disc with three additional songs.

1. THE RECIPE (FEAT. DR. DRE)
Dre didn't produce this one either (he landed a co-production credit somehow, but I'm sure he just mixed it and nothing more), but “The Recipe”, K-Dot's ode to the “women, weed, and weather” of Cali, still sounds fucking great today. It definitely doesn't fit the overall theme Kendrick was going for on the proper album, so I do understand why it was committed to the bonus track ward. Andre's vocals on here are so obviously Kendrick's that, when Kendrick appeared on BET's recent Hip Hop Awards show to perform Dre's verse, it didn't even click until halfway through that it was, in fact, Dre's verse that he was reciting. Scoop DeVille's Twin Sister-sampling beat still bangs hard today. The hell with the fact that it apparently signifies a shift toward a Kendrick Lamar model that “sold out”: if it draws more people to the project and sounds good while doing so, what's the harm?

2. BLACK BOY FLY
I liked the instrumental, and the verses themselves sounded okay, but “Black Boy Fly” never gelled for me, as the bars continually clashed with said beat, and K-Dot's introduction was motherfucking terrible. I liked the overall story, though, as our host breaks down his train of thought when he decided to pursue this here rap shit as a career. Too bad this track wasn't better.

3. NOW OR NEVER (FEAT. MARY J. BLIGE)
I'm pretty sure that Mary J. Blige has made more appearances in a cameo capacity on rap songs than she has on her own goddamn albums: it used to be a stab at legitimacy when you managed to get her on your album, but now it seems she'll work for anyone who'll write her a check (including Burger King, but I digress). She's now just a part of a checklist label A&Rs print out when they're in charge of putting a project together. At least she isn't just limited to the hook on “Now Or Never”, but I still didn't care for this shit: even with Jack Splash's okay-ish production, I could still see the numbers hidden beneath the shoddy paint job.

In an effort to branch out as much as possible, Kendrick Lamar provided different additional bonus songs to different outlets, specifically iTunes, Spotify, and Target. One of them, the iTunes-exclusive “Swimming Pools (Drank) (Single Version)”, is self-explanatory, but the other five, although easy to track down, haven't graced my ears as of yet. Here's where you come in: I want you, the reader, to listen to the extra bonus tracks and let everyone else know what is and isn't worth hunting down in the comments section below. My burnt-out self appreciates it.

THE LAST WORD:  Prepare yourself, because I'm going to say something you may not appreciate: there are songs on Kendrick Lamar's good kid, m.A.A.d. city that aren't very good.  There, I said it.  A handful of these songs will never be listened to by me again, because the beat was bland, or the voice being utilized on the track gave me a headache, or whatever my reasoning is (I'd say I don't have to explain everything to you, but that's kind of what I'm supposed to be doing on this blog).  Are you finished screaming at your computer or iPad screen yet?  Okay, now here's the rest of the review: the songs that are good on good kid, m.A.A.d. city, and yes, I mean "songs" in the plural form, are fucking excellent, and they elevate the entire project to the level of what is quite possibly the best major label release of 2012.  Thanks to his time toiling in the mixtape mines, Kendrick comes out the gate with the knowledge of how to not only write an actual rap song, but how to best get his point across: aside from the handful of poor tracks, which are easily overlooked in the iTunes age (just don't upload those songs, duh), the only rookie mistake he makes on his major label debut is in including those really fucking long interludes, which were intended to keep the story moving, but cause the album to grind to a halt whenever they pop up.  I understand that the subtitle of this album is A Short Film By Kendrick Lamar, but it might have been too bold a choice to go with a concept album right out of the box.  Still, Kendrick has a mostly excellent ear for beats, and even if he doesn't always connect with his different flows, he at least always sounds interesting.  good kid, m.A.A.d. city is actually successful overall; he at least won me over, as I have yet to listen to any of his previous projects, but now I suddenly feel the need to do so.  So yeah, I would recommend that you pick this one up, if only for "The Art Of Peer Pressure", which is one the best songs I've heard during my run on this site.  And that's not hyperbole.

-Max

RELATED POSTS:

36 comments:

  1. Pretty much agreed with everything you wrote here, Max (although I do really like Compton as the closer, but I know you aren't the biggest Just Blaze fan either). Completely right about Poetic Justice and ESPECIALLY Real, which I couldn't fucking stand (not to mention it's nearly 8 minutes long...) but overall this was a solid debut for Kendrick. I think I like Section.80 just a little bit more though.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm kind of surprised you didn't love Bitch Don't Kill my Vibe, Money Trees, and Swimming Pools more, but yeah this album fucking rocks. Kendrick is redefining rap music and nobody can keep up with him

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really like "Swimming Pools (Drank)". I thought my notes up there conveyed that. In case they didn't, I really do like that song. The other two, yeah, not my cup of tea.

      Delete
    2. I just reread your comments on the song I'm a dum dum and thanks for the week of reviews it was coo

      Delete
  3. let me say this now...you're gonna piss alot of people off for saying this wasn't the greatest thing since sliced bread Max. I will also say that i love the hell out of this (every song except Now or Never) and i think the skits make the story better, but i'm not going to catch feelings over you not completely agreeing with me, because thats just fucking juvenile.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. oh yeah, and as far as the bonus tracks are concerned, (because we all ignored Max's requests) Swimming Pools remix is enjoyable but doesn't hit nearly as hard as the original, mainly because the concept behind the track is gone, I like The Recipe remix more than the original, Collect Calls is pretty damn good, with Kendrick trying to get his mom to bail him out of jail, and County Building Blues is okay, nothing special. And although it's not a bonus track, i would recommend listening to The Heart Pt. 3. Kendrick dropped it like a week before the album came out and it gives an introduction to GKMC i guess you could say

      Delete
  4. Did Max just admit to driving while intoxicated? Discuss.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think so. I do not condone his behavior.

      Oh yeah, Kendrick Lamar is overrated. There, I said it.

      Delete
    2. yeah, i kind of did a double-take there.

      Delete
    3. No, he said that he was "driving home drunkenly". Kind of like how an old kung-fu movie has guys running around with "drunk" fighting styles. Max' driving style is like that.

      Delete
  5. Listen to, and review, Section 80. It's better.

    ReplyDelete
  6. max,review some of the material Death Grips, The Money Store (released this year) is possibly one of the best most forward thinking hip-hop albums which has been recently released

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. you should know that you can't just tell people to listen to Death Grips. Only certain people will like Death Grips

      Delete
  7. Some songs for me were passable, but all in all I will be playing once in a while only the boom bap-esque part of ''m.a.a.d city''. Probably am too old for this ''new rap'' and can't understand it. For me there is nothing special about this album and I don't give a fuck if you disagree.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. my man, there's nothing special about this album. It's just not terribly wack, which is saying something in today's hip hop. I find the whole project bland as fuck. Kendrick has an irritating voice and average beat selection. With that said, I absolutely agree with Max that "Peer Pressure" and "The Recipe" are Kendrick's best songs. It's so obvious when you listen to them. They have great beats (which is extremely important), and some decent rhymes. I think LiveLoveASAP is superior to this album in some many ways, mostly because Clams Casino's production is unlike anything I've heard in hip hop. It's ethereal boom bap. Check it out and let me know what you think. Start with ASAP Rocky's "Bass".

      Delete
  8. Replies
    1. in due time my friend...an album can't be a classic if it's been out for a week

      Delete
    2. fair enough, I'm a 90s baby never really witnessed a 'classic' dropping

      Delete
  9. The Recipe is worth tracking down. It's an ode to Californian lifestyle and has a nice, smooth beat produced by Scoop DeVille (people who know his beats know what I'm talking about). Dre comes with a verse ghostwritten by Kendrick so that's that.

    ReplyDelete
  10. @max not sure if you noticed but the second part of maaad city is basically a remix of ice cube's a bird in the hand, a FANTASTIC track

    ReplyDelete
  11. The Big DickOctober 27, 2012

    Hmmmm sounds like a slightly less wasted version of Quasimoto

    ReplyDelete
  12. I just listened to this album. I would like to say that KL has some inspiration plus he has something to say. His voice is weird though, I can't imagine why he has to switch the pitch up and down on almost every song.

    On the other hand, I don't think that the idea for a concept album was his own... In my eyes, Dr. Dre is behind all this trying to give an alternative tone of a today's Compton rapper. Maybe KL intends to be a conscious rapper from Compton, this would be a new combination in Hip Hop. However, the whole thing was surprisingly different, compared to other releases.

    The tracks who stand out are "M.A.A.D. city" (thanks to Mc Eiht and to the fantastic beat after halftime) and "Compton".

    To the Anonymous who said that the second part of "M.A.A.D. city" is a remix of "A bird in the hand": the first two lines kicked by KL are the same ones with the original lyrics of the song, the rest is new. Only after recognizing the origin of these two lines, you realize that the beat of the song is similar to the original, but remixed (different bass line and keys).

    ReplyDelete
  13. @Kay-Em-Dee

    "On the other hand, I don't think that the idea for a concept album was his own... In my eyes, Dr. Dre is behind all this trying to give an alternative tone of a today's Compton rapper."


    No. Why would you even say that? This all Kendrick, 100%. If you would've heard some of his previous records you'd know that. And lol @ Dre coming with any sort of concept album when he had other people ghostwrite his lyrics all his career.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Truth is, that I don't know Kendrick Lamar's previous work. Just a view singles here and there. The reason why I said that Dre is behind this concept album, is beacause it's Dr. Dre himself who produced it. Plus I don't think that Kandrick has 100% creative control.

      Delete
  14. The beat for Sing About Me, which i liked way more than the other half, reminded me of Biggie's I Got A Story To Tell. Anyway good review!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Strange music is tech n9nes label. i loved this album but felt it would have been perfect for dre to produce the whole thing in an effort to prove he hasn't fallen off. as kendrick wouldn't sound himself over dre's usual beats (Heavy piano keys, synths and so on) i would have been a great chance to reinvent himself like he did from DOC and NWA to G Funk and Snoop to his modern 2001 stuff and Eminem. because his latest beats on Obie, xzibit and raekwons albums all sound like paint by numbers dr dre instrumentals that dj khallil scoop deville or scott storch could have produced. i mean the two formally supposed lead singles from detox werent even produced by dre they were produced by alex da kid and dj khallil

    ReplyDelete
  16. listened to a track or two while shuffling through new releases on spotify but skipped after hearing raps about weed smoking which always bores the hell out of me. guess i'll give it another chance!

    ReplyDelete
  17. good review, and a good album. Completely unrelated but are you going to review Q-tip's Kamaal the Abstract at some point?

    ReplyDelete
  18. Strange music is tech n9ne's label

    ReplyDelete
  19. I completely agree with everything said in this review, which is shocking because I don't think I've ever said that before about any review. I'm surprised you never listened to Kendrick before this though Max, section.80 is another solid album though even more "up and down" than GKMC. Can you review Control System by Ab-Soul and Habits & Contradictions by Schoolboy Q? Blue Chips and Rare Chandeliers as well

    ReplyDelete
  20. Loved your review! But give "Bitch Don't Kill my vibe" and especially "Money trees" a few more go rounds. Their probably my favorite songs on the album. As good as this album was i put it third behind "Overly Dedicated" and (first) section.80. Reason being I didn't really care for the concept of this album. The concept of section.80 felt more clear to me. Review those first two!

    ReplyDelete
  21. OH the concept is CLEAR to me now lol. i spoke too soon before the last 2 tracks kicked in. I should elaborate that this album was exactly about a "good kid" in a "mad city" which is what everyone expected and should be easy to understand (don't mind me lol) But its weird because section.80 delves more into peoples problems and what we should look forward to in the eyes of KL. Its more social and political in my eyes than good kid mad city. Overly Dedicated is more like this album but its speaking directly from Kendricks experience. And it has a few more good songs than this. That's why i put it above this. So yeah, review those 2! lol

    ReplyDelete
  22. This is fair but like others said, Bitch don't kill my vibe and money trees are the best songs on this album. I liked the former immediately but I definitely had to listen to Money trees for a few weeks before I realized its genius. Overall, I agree with you that GKMC isn't the best thing since sliced bread, it DOES have bad songs. BUT when you make a playlist out of the best songs from GKMC, Section.80, and OD, you're now God.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I'd say Kendricks best song out of all his works is The Heart Pt. 2.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Max, would you recommend buying the deluxe or normal edition of this?

    ReplyDelete